Certificate: 15
Running Time: 106 mins
UK Distributor: Universal Pictures
UK Release Date: 20 November 2026
Helen Mirren, Alden Ehrenreich, Olivia Cooke, Juliet Stevenson, James Faulkner
Anton Corbijn (director), Joanna Murray-Smith (writer), Carolyn Marks Blackwood, Mickey Liddell, Troy Lum, Kurt Martin, Andrea Occhipinti, Jim Robison, Pete Shilaimon, Karl Spoerri and Gabrielle Tana (producers), Dickon Hinchliffe (composer), Robbie Ryan (cinematographer), Andrew Hulme (editor)
A literary agent (Ehrenreich) tries to persuade Patricia Highsmith (Mirren) to write one last thriller…
Throughout her life and career, Patricia Highsmith – the novelist best known for the oft-adapted The Talented Mr. Ripley – expressed little desire for the fame she had incurred. Already known for making few public appearances, the author developed a reputation for being rude and even racially insensitive, especially in her later years when she lived a reclusive life in Switzerland, far away from the adoring public she had no interest in patronising.
Although A Talent for Murder features a very much fictional rendition of Highsmith herself (a fact that is made abundantly clear during the ending title cards), director Anton Corbijn’s film captures her uncouth and sometimes repugnant personality all too well, but also her unmistakable penchant for crafting some devilishly intense thrillers about the vilest and most evil people that any creative could imagine. However, the end result doesn’t always leave one feeling as satisfied as they would reading one of Highsmith’s own novels.
In 1995, Highsmith (played by Helen Mirren) is living in the Swiss countryside, effectively drowning herself in alcohol and minding her own business when, all of a sudden, a young American named Edward (Alden Ehrenreich) shows up outside her home. He’s a literary editor who has been sent by his superiors to try and persuade Highsmith to write one more novel featuring her most famous creation, the murderous con artist Tom Ripley. Naturally, Highsmith won’t even entertain the idea at first, but as Edward demonstrates a strong understanding of her work, she challenges him to help her come up with a crime that only Ripley himself could commit.
This is where we transition to the story-within-the-story, which is where A Talent for Murder perhaps shines brightest. It indeed features Ripley (also Ehrenreich) as he travels to Italy and sets his eyes on young heiress Clementine (Olivia Cooke) – named after the young woman that Edward met on the train to Switzerland, who is also played by Cooke – whom he charms and seduces into accepting a very early marriage proposal, before then setting into motion plans to off her wealthy relatives who control the vast wealth that she will one day inherit. In other words, classic Tom Ripley.
These sequences are among the film’s most compelling and the most satisfying, as Corbijn and screenwriter Joanna Murray-Smith (the latter adapting her own play Switzerland) embrace the slick and suave yet undeniably sociopathic nature of the very character that Highsmith originally created, themselves crafting a narrative which the author herself may not have exactly been happy with (compared to some of Ripley’s other outings, it’s a somewhat safe and predictable affair) but nonetheless captures the essence of her work. It’s almost hypnotic watching Ehrenreich’s Ripley do what Ripley does best, for not only does the actor demonstrate a magnetic presence as his cool charisma and later his steely-eyed nothingness pierce their way into his target’s souls, but Corbijn’s equally smooth direction lends such scenes a frightful tone where you can’t stop yourself from rooting for this absolute monster of a man as he lies and kills his way to glory. The homage is well done enough to make you wish that this was the whole movie instead, or at least much more than what we actually get.
Instead, though, we get a rather muted chamber piece between Ehrenreich’s other character and Mirren’s Highsmith, one that sets up so much promise only to not do a whole lot with it. Initially, there is a lot to like about this on-screen pairing, as Highsmith’s uncouth cantankerousness frequently clashes with Edward’s reserved nature, a dynamic that slowly begins to shift the more that they interact with one another, and both actors are a hoot as they lunge at each other’s throats (quite literally in one case) with carefully chosen words and sometimes other actual weapons among their arsenals. At times, Corbijn even utilises a neat Hitchcockian visual style for some surprisingly effective moments, like an early jump-scare that is strikingly framed by the director and lit by cinematographer Robbie Ryan. But quickly, much of that subsides when it becomes clear that Murray-Smith’s script isn’t leading the viewer anywhere that makes what we’ve seen have that much of a point (I have no idea if her original stage play is the same way, or if much of it was muted for this screen version). It becomes more frustrating as it never really builds up to something substantial other than some rather vague character decisions that raise more questions than answers, while Corbijn’s deliberate slow pace tends to drag out certain reveals further than they need to, diluting their overall impact.
With a concept like this, particularly the one where the author of a revered piece of work is drawn into a narrative of their own making, A Talent for Murder should be more engaging than it is. But while it certainly captures the smooth and mysterious storytelling that Patricia Highsmith became renowned for (much to her own chagrin, presumably), it doesn’t exactly follow through on delivering the sense of satisfaction one gets from her work, since it keeps the cards it’s been dealt way too close to its chest and alienates the viewer with its refusal to let anyone else see their hand. Luckily, some enjoyable performances – particularly from Mirren, who is having a blast as this extremely unpleasant rendition of Highsmith – keep it afloat, though don’t expect this to deliver the same level of thrills as your average Tom Ripley misadventure.
A Talent for Murder is a stylish but uneven thriller that pays strong homage to the slick works of Patricia Highsmith and features a fun central turn by Helen Mirren as a fictional version of the author herself, though its inability to provide clarity on certain developments leaves it considerably less satisfying than the writer’s best works.
0 Comments